An independent artist's hilarious encounter with supposedly personalized music-industry marketing.
When Music Marketing Meets an Empty Spotify Profile 👻🎧
As an independent songwriter and music creator, I receive my fair share of promotional emails from companies offering everything from music distribution and playlist placements to royalty collection services.
Most of them end up where they belong: in my spam folder.
But every now and then, an email arrives that's simply too entertaining to ignore.
This time, it came from a music royalty collection company called Bridger. A representative named Romain contacted me, saying he had come across my Spotify profile and noticed that I'd worked on track composition.
How lovely! Someone had discovered my music!
There was just one tiny, rather hilarious problem.
My Spotify artist profile is EMPTY!!!
Not because I've stopped making music. Quite the opposite! I have an extensive catalogue of original songs, but I've deliberately chosen not to distribute my music on Spotify.
Apparently, Romain had discovered something even more extraordinary than my compositions: music that doesn't exist on the platform he claimed to have visited.
Now, let's be clear. This article isn't an accusation that Bridger is a fraudulent company. It's about something independent artists encounter far too often: marketing messages that create the impression of genuine, personalized outreach without demonstrating any real familiarity with the artist.
And since the email also raised the subject of mechanical royalties, I thought this would be the perfect opportunity to combine a little music-industry education with a healthy dose of sarcasm.
So, dear fellow independent artists, grab your coffee, put on your headphones, and join me for a rather unusual musical discovery.
And Romain, if you're reading this, I have a few questions for you. 😉
Dear Romain, Congratulations!
You have accomplished something truly extraordinary.
You discovered my music on Spotify.
There's just one tiny problem.
I DON'T HAVE ANY MUSIC ON SPOTIFY!!!!
Not one song. Not one album. Not even a lonely Christmas single waiting for Santa to discover it.
And yet, according to your email, you came across my Spotify profile and noticed that I've worked on track composition.
Fascinating!
Did you listen to my invisible discography? Were you particularly impressed by the silence between my nonexistent tracks? Or did Spotify introduce a new feature called Imagination Mode without telling me?
Because, Romain, I have questions. SO MANY QUESTIONS.
The Miracle of Personalized Mass Marketing
Your email begins:
"I came across your Spotify and wanted to reach out."
How wonderfully personal!
Except that my Spotify artist profile is empty.
Now, I understand that marketing teams need to find potential customers. There's nothing wrong with that.
But implying you've personally researched an artist when your message gives every impression of being a generic marketing template?
That's not meaningful personalization.
That's automation wearing a fake moustache.
And here's a little marketing tip, free of charge: if you're going to mention an artist's Spotify profile, perhaps check whether there's actually any music on it.
Thirty seconds of research can save everyone a rather embarrassing conversation.
Or, in this case, inspire an entire blog post. 😉
Dear Independent Artists, Here's the Serious Part
Behind the comedy is something worth discussing.
Music royalties are complicated. Performance royalties, mechanical royalties, master recording income, and publishing administration are not interchangeable.
Performance royalties for musical compositions generally arise from public performances, including certain broadcasts and streams. Mechanical royalties relate to reproductions and certain digital uses of compositions. Master recording royalties concern the sound recording itself.
Different organizations and agreements may cover different rights, territories, and income streams.
Before signing up with another royalty collection company, ask yourself:
Which royalties does this company actually collect?
Am I already collecting them through my performing rights organization (PRO), publisher, collective management organization (CMO), or publishing administrator?
Will this agreement overlap with an existing contract?
What percentage will the company retain?
Are there exclusivity clauses, termination restrictions, or other obligations?
Which countries and territories are covered?
Before registering with a new collection service, check whether your existing publishing administrator already collects the same royalties in the same territories.
And remember: Free registration does not necessarily mean free service.
In this particular email, Bridger offers to collect mechanical royalties while retaining 10% of the royalties earned through its service.
That may be a legitimate business model. But whether it offers any additional value depends on the artist's existing arrangements.
The lesson is simple: don't sign up for another royalty collection service just because an email suggests you might be missing money.
Do your homework first.
And perhaps expect the company approaching you to have done a little homework, too.
A Final Word to Romain
Dear Romain,
Next time you contact an independent artist, perhaps spend thirty seconds checking whether the music you appear to have discovered actually exists on the platform you're mentioning.
Independent artists work incredibly hard. We write, compose, produce, distribute, promote, administer rights, and manage our own businesses.
We deserve better than manufactured familiarity disguised as personal attention.
And if you genuinely enjoyed my Spotify catalogue, please tell me which track was your favourite.
**I'm particularly proud of my latest release: "The Sound of Absolutely Nothing." :-) **
With musical regards,
Lily Amis
Independent Songwriter & Music Creator

No comments:
Post a Comment